Wednesday, 22 March 2023
SCOTLAND WITHIN THE UNITED KINGDOM (2007)
Sunday, 19 February 2023
ANYONE FANCY A BY-ELECTION IN GLASGOW SOUTHSIDE?
Just a thought: what if Nicola Sturgeon didn't put her feet up and settle into the back-benches at Holyrood until the next Scottish Parliament Election in three-years time? What if, instead, Nicola Sturgeon stood-down as MSP for the Glasgow Southside constituency?
If the outgoing First Minister took that course of action, there would be a by-election to select a new MSP for the Glasgow constituency. At the 2021 Scottish Parliament Election, the Labour candidate in Glasgow Southside was Anas Sarwar. A candidate cannot contest an election to the Scottish Parliament if they already hold a seat at Holyrood [Scotland Act 1998: Section 9]. So, if Sarwar was to contest a by-election in Glasgow Southside, he would first have to stand-down as a Regional List MSP for Glasgow.
Of course, Sarwar might choose not to be the Labour candidate at such a by-election, but what would that say about how he thinks his party is likely to perform in Scotland? Would the leader of the Labour Party in Scotland really allow the country to see that he, personally, was feart to fight the SNP in a one-off by-election?
So, if Nicola Sturgeon stood down as an MSP, creating a by-election in Glasgow Southside, the pressure would be on Anas Sarwar to lead from the front for Labour and to contest the seat. Would Sarwar have the courage to do that, given he would have to stand-down from his current position as a List MSP for Glasgow and, if he didn't win the by-election, he would be out of the Scottish Parliament until 2026? On the plus side for Anas Sarwar, though, is the chance he could be the Labour candidate who took the seat of the former SNP First Minister.
Just for background: the first Scottish Parliament constituency by-election was in March 2000, just 10-months after the first full elections in 1999. Labour MSP Ian Welsh stood-down in the Ayr constituency. At the 1999 Election, the Tory candidate was Phil Gallie, who had previously been the MP for Ayr. Labour's majority was just 25. Despite this, Gallie chose not to fight the by-election, which would have required him to stand-down as a List MSP for South of Scotland. In the 2000 by-election, the Tories took Ayr with Labour falling to third behind the SNP.
In 2006, on the death of SNP MSP Margaret Ewing, there was a by-election in the Moray constituency. Richard Lochhead for the SNP and Mary Scanlon for the Tories were both sitting List MSPs representing the North East Scotland Region. Both stood-down to contest the constituency by-election. Richard Lochhead won for the SNP, while Mary Scanlon finished second and was out of parliament until the 2007 Scottish Parliament Election when she was again returned as a Regional List MSP for North East Scotland.
So, if Nicola Sturgeon stood-down as an MSP and created a by-election in the Glasgow Southside constituency, would Anas Sarwar be prepared to stand-down as a Regional List MSP for Glasgow to contest the constituency seat, or would he bottle-it, remain as a List MSP and send the message that he doesn't think Labour would win with him as the candidate?
Ultimately, a decision on whether or not to call a by-election in Glasgow Southside lies with Nicola Sturgeon and the SNP. If they haven't considered the position a by-election would place Anas Sarwar, they should have. Of course the SNP would have to consider that they might lose a by-election. However, given that the SNP majority in Glasgow Southside at the 2021 Scottish Parliament Election was 9,465, surely the party could not throw away such a massive electoral advantage. Actually, given the state of today's gender-obsessed SNP, they might want to sit tight, even if that lets Anas Sarwar off the by-election hook.
Thursday, 24 June 2021
COUNCILLORS IGNORE WARNINGS OVER PROPOSED SCHOOL SITE
Labour, SNP and Tory councillors joined together at Wednesday's meeting of North Ayrshire Council (June 23) to throw-out a proposal from Saltcoats Independent councillor Ronnie McNicol, which called for the local authority to stop plans for new schools and a leisure centre to be built on the former Shell-Mex oil and bitumen refinery in Ardrossan.
A report compiled by Council officers, and which included the opinions of Envirocentre, the local authority's contractor for the 'North Shore' site in Ardrossan, was presented, with councillors asked to “note” the findings. However, in an amendment, Cllr McNicol moved that officers be instructed “not to proceed with the plan to build new schools and leisure facilities on toxic, contaminated land at the former Shell-Mex site in Ardrossan”.
In addition, Ronnie McNicol asked councillors to support his call that officers also should examine if the land at the 'North Shore' site could ever be safely used “for any purpose”, such as an environmental beach-park and walkway. The Saltcoats councillor further argued that officers should “investigate why Shell was allowed to walk away from Ardrossan, leaving behind a large area of highly toxic, contaminated land”.
The Council report supported the opinion of Envirocentre that the toxic land could be cleaned sufficiently to allow for schools and a leisure facility to be built on it and used by local people, including school pupils aged 5-to-18.
However, speaking to his amendment, Cllr McNicol pointed out that Envirocentre, themselves, said their proposals to clean the land would only “limit risk to human health”. The Independent councillor said, “Note it does not say it will remove risk to human health. Why not build schools on a site that does not present a risk to human health? Even a limited risk to human health presents the chance that, in the future, young people, teachers and other facility users could become unwell, possibly seriously unwell. Why take that chance when there are numerous other, and safe, sites that could be used?”
Reading from the Council/Envirocentre report, Cllr McNicol referred to a long-list of contaminants in the soil of the 'North Shore' site, including: heavy metals, asbestos, arsenic, cadmium, chromium, copper, lead, mercury, selenium and zinc.
Addressing councillors, Ronnie McNicol said, “On Arsenic, the World Health Organisation states: 'Early childhood exposure to Arsenic has been linked to negative impacts on cognitive development and increased deaths in young adults'.
“Of Asbestos, the Health & Safety Executive says: 'When materials that contain asbestos are disturbed or damaged, fibres are released into the air. When these fibres are inhaled they can cause serious diseases. These diseases will not affect you immediately; they often take a long time to develop, but once diagnosed, it is often too late to do anything'.
“NHS Inform says of Lead: 'Exposure to Lead can be harmful especially to unborn babies and young children. Children absorb more lead than adults due to their growing bones and other organs', with a prominent symptom of Lead poisoning in children being 'developmental delay and learning difficulties'.
“Of Mercury, the World Health Organisation says: 'Exposure to mercury – even small amounts – may cause serious health problems, and is a threat to the development of children'.”
The long-serving councillor continued, “Membranes are to be laid across the site, in the hope that this will stop contaminants from reaching the surface. Then, environmental capping will be applied to certain areas. Environmental capping is laying down topsoil to a general depth of 60cm or just 2ft of safe soil.
“Again, despite claims that contaminants will be removed, the report states that the footprint of all buildings will have hydrocarbon and ground gas resistant membranes installed, while water supply pipes and utility service connections will require additional protection – all to try and minimise the impact of 'residual contaminants'. So, all contaminants are not expected to be removed, and yet the Council proposes to build schools on this land.”
Cllr McNicol concluded, “There are numerous other sites – safe sites – in the local area that could be used for new schools and leisure facilities. This proposal for the former Shell Mex site should not go ahead. It is madness.
“All I can say to councillors who might be minded to support building schools on a toxic, contaminated site is: I hope you are right that the site can be cleaned. I hope you are right, because if you are not right, and in the future young people and teachers become ill, then responsibility for that will be on your heads.”
Despite Cllr McNicol's chilling warnings of the contaminants at the proposed school site, and how they present specific dangers to young people, all Labour and SNP councillors present at the meeting voted against the amendment and for the report to continue with proposals to build new schools and a leisure centre. All-but-one of the Tory Group also voted to ignore Ronnie McNicol's warnings.
Cllr McNicol's amendment received support from his fellow Independent councillors, Robert Barr, Ian Murdoch, Donald L Reid, and one Tory, John Glover.